RIIC - Helping journalists tell better Indigenous news stories.

News Stereotypes of Aboriginal Peoples

The myth of the drunken Indian has been retired in favour of the legend of the crooked band council.
–    Stephen Hume

An elder once told me the only way an Indian would make it on the news is if he or she was one of the 4Ds: drumming, dancing, drunk, or dead.

C’mon, I said, that’s simplistic. I can show you all kinds of different news stories — about Aboriginal workers running a forestry operation, an Aboriginal student winning a scholarship or an Aboriginal group repatriating a sacred artifact.

But, then I started looking more closely at Aboriginal people in the news. Those 4Ds sure do show up an awful lot (if that repatriation event has some drumming and dancing goin’ on, the reporter is bound to squeeze both into the story).

In fact, if you take that elder’s four “Ds,” and add a “W” for Warrior, you could make it a rule.

The WD4 Rule on How Indians Make The News

1.  Be a Warrior.

Credit: Shaney Komulainen (CP)

It’s a photo so iconic it has a title. “Face to Face.” A baby-faced soldier staring down a masked warrior.

Shaney Komulainen’s snapshot during the Oka Crisis in 1990 so perfectly captured longstanding racial and national tensions that The Beaver magazine named it one of the top five News Photos That Changed Canada.

But consider a different photo, also captured during the Oka Crisis, one that doesn’t have a title. Maybe it should. “Media Circus.”

Credit: Department of National Defence


It is equally telling, about how media actively shape perceptions about confrontation and conflict between Canada and Aboriginal peoples.

Why does direct action by Aboriginal groups (such as marches, blockades, or occupations) receive disproportionate attention from news media? Yes, protests often meet the test of whether a story is “newsworthy,” because they’re unusual, dramatic, or involve conflict. Yes, aboriginal activists, who understand the media’s hunger for drama, also play a role by tailoring protests in ways that guarantee prominent headlines and lead stories.

But, does today’s front-page news of some traffic disruption in the name of Aboriginal land rights actually have it’s roots in a much older narrative – of violent and “uncivilized” Indians who represent a threat to “progress” in Canada? Are attitudes of distrust and fear underlying our decisions to dispatch a crew to the latest Aboriginal blockade? Is there no iconic photo of reconcilation, because no one from the newsrooms believes harmony between aboriginal peoples and settlers is “newsworthy”?

2.  Beat your Drum.

It’s easy to laugh, these days, at those ridiculous Hollywood Indian stereotypes of yesteryear: Indians wearing feathers, grunting in monosyllables, “circling the wagons”. But contemporary news stories continue to reproduce the mainstay of those old Westerns – the Indian drums.

Credit: Jason Payne (Postmedia News)

Even if you’re not a fan of cowboy movies, you probably learned that “Indian” beat in the schoolyard — BMMM bmmm bmmm bmmm BMMM bmmm bmmm bmmm BMMM bmmm bmmm bmmm. Indians about to ride over the hill, on the warpath. Indians doing a raindance. That sort of thing.

Well, how many broadcast news stories start with Aboriginal drumming? Reporters seem entranced by those drums, whether they be Aboriginal protests or Aboriginal celebrations (if there’s no drums around, heaven forbid, then hurry up and find some flute music for the background track!)

Sure, I get it. You need sound and action to start your piece with a kick.

But do you ask the purpose and meaning of the song? Is it an honour song, a prayer song, a memorial song? Do you request a translation of the lyrics, or describe it as “chanting?” Or do you just let those frozen-in-time Indians beat their drums, leaving it to your audience to interpret (I bet many heave a mighty sigh, “Oh, drums. Indians on the warpath. What do they want THIS TIME?”)

3.  Start Dancing.

Credit: CBC News

The dancing thing goes hand-in-hand with drumming. Indians in traditional regalia fit a popular but superficial interpretation of Canadian multiculturalism. Please, share your entertaining costumes and dances and, yes, we’d love to taste your exotic food!

Actually, Indians outfitted in buckskin and feathers (whether real Indians like Pauline Johnson or fake Indians like Grey Owl) have long been objects of fascination and even admiration.

Credit: Jeff McIntosh (CP)

To many Canadians, an Aboriginal person wearing a button blanket or beaded vest represents a bygone era. Dressed-up Indians are benign, without all those messy contemporary problems – suicides and land claims, mouldy houses and tax exemption.

Newsrooms are not immune to this nostalgia for “Indians.” Why are chiefs so often portrayed wearing traditional regalia (rather than dashing through airports, barking into cellphones?) How many TV newscasts use an over-the-shoulder graphic of a feather to signify an “Indian” story? Is it powwow time again – get a camera over there!

Trust me. If you’re an Aboriginal person and you want to make the news, haul out your headdress (or give one to the Prime Minister).

4.  Get Drunk.

No question, alcohol is at the root of many stories reporters cover in Aboriginal communities – car accidents, murders, assaults, and the like.

Credit: judychartrand.com

But does that age-old stereotype of the “drunken Indian” have any basis in reality?

No, asserted the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples (RCAP), after examining several studies that show abstinence is twice as frequent among Indians as it is in the non-Aboriginal community. Heavy drinking is more prevalent among Aboriginal people than it is in the mainstream, but the proportion of people who drink on a daily basis is seven times higher among non-Aboriginal people than among Aboriginal people. “The widely held belief that most Aboriginal people consume excessive amounts of alcohol on a regular basis appears to be incorrect,” RCAP concluded.

Do the countless stories we cover about Aboriginal people involving alcohol help reinforce the myth of the “drunken Indian”? Ask yourself: is alcohol relevant to the story, and why? The media often stays mum about the drinking habits of notable Canadian politicians — would alcohol be part of your story if this was about a non-Aboriginal person?


5.  Be Dead.

Credit: CTV News

Go to news search engine such as Google News and search “dead” and “First Nations” (or synonyms such as “native” or “Aboriginal”). I’ll bet my grandmother’s dreamcatcher your cup overfloweth with news from across the country.

Newsrooms have this thing for death, anywhere its happening. “It bleeds, it leads,” right? Sadly, in Canada, there’s a disproportionate amount of death happening in Aboriginal communities. Maybe that explains why we see so many dead Indians in the news.

But, what does this constant barrage of dead Indians tell our audiences about Aboriginal communities in Canada? That Aboriginal life in Canada is, to quote Thomas Hobbes and one infamous judge in British Columbia, “nasty, brutish and short”? Or, nefariously, that “the only good Indian is a dead Indian”?


OK, I admit, I’m trying to stir the pot with the WD4 Rule. Still, research shows news reports from Aboriginal communities tend to follow extremely narrow guidelines based on pre-existing stereotypes of Indians.

But, first, let’s take a step back and ask — what is a stereotype anyway?

Whether we’re aware of it or not, reporters use stereotypes. A lot. News happens fast, and we need quick ways to simplify our storylines to make sure our audience “gets it.”

Credit: CBC News

Stereotypes act like codes, giving audiences an instant, common understanding of a person or group of people—usually relating to their class, ethnicity or race, gender, sexual orientation, social role or occupation (for example, “NHL hockey players have physical stamina” is a safe assumption, even if it’s not based on statistical fact).

Things get problematic when stereotypes are based on untruths, and, unfortunately, there’s ample evidence of journalists basing stereotypes about Aboriginal peoples on false assumptions. By repeating stereotypes, we have the power to transform assumptions about Aboriginal peoples into “realities,” which reinforces discrimination and prejudice.

Stereotypes of Aboriginal peoples in the media tend to shift, depending on the concerns of the age. In fact, there’s evidence the WD4 Rule is being replaced by more complex, more refined stereotypes.

In 1996, when the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples examined representations of Aboriginal peoples in the media, they concluded many Canadians know Aboriginal people only as the Pathetic Victim, the Nobel Environmentalist, or the Angry Warrior:

Aboriginal people are portrayed in a historical past reconstructed in present stereotypes: the noble Red Man roaming free in the forest; the bloodthirsty savage attacking the colony or the wagon train; the drunken Indian; the Aboriginal environmentalist; and, most recently, the warrior in para-military dress, wielding a gun… As with all stereotypes, there is a kernel of truth in the images, which assume a dramatic profile and become etched in the popular consciousness. But stereotypes block out complexity of context and diversity of personality and perspective.

In 2002, Crystal Maslin used her Master’s thesis to examine how Saskatchewan newspapers have constructed portrayals of Aboriginal peoples, identifying two used most frequently:

  • The “Troublemaker” — politically active Aboriginal peoples portrayed as advocating for recognition of rights and the promise of government funds, at the expense of other Canadians; and
  • The “Good Indian” — individuals who are successful according to the standards of dominant society by not relying on welfare and paying income tax, despite his or her racial background (implying that it is personal deficiencies rather than structural barriers that prevent widespread Aboriginal success).

Credit: Reuters

In 2005, Robert Harding, a social work professor, found the “native-as-environmentalist” stereotype is waning, while a new stereotype is emerging: Aboriginal people as “incompetent or corrupt financial managers.” Harding suggests this pattern of news discourse “protects the status quo while limiting the potential for Aboriginal self-determination.” While self-governance may be the ultimate goal for many Aboriginal peoples, Harding wrote “others may see these aspirations primarily in terms of the threat they pose to their lifestyle and standard of living.”

There are many other ways media “frame” news stories about Aboriginal peoples, and there are certainly regional variations (for example, “native-as-gangster” news stories abound in the Prairies, just as “casino-rich Indians” stories are common in the United States). I’ve highlighted some here; if you’re interested in more detailed analysis, check out the References section.

Not to further complicate matters, but as you journey to Aboriginal communities, you may find Aboriginal people sometimes encourage, expand and even exploit the stereotypes. How many Aboriginal baseball teams are called the Braves, or Aboriginal hockey teams dubbed the Chiefs? What’s a reporter supposed to make of that, huh?

Here’s the bottom-line: as journalists, our first obligation is to the truth. We need to convey accurate facts in context. That means, when covering Aboriginal communities, we need to resist the shortcut of stereotypes.

Be conscious of your own personal and cultural biases. Verify the information you report. Otherwise, you risk undermining the accuracy of your work, and adding fuel to the fire of existing stereotypes.

It Girl Facebook Game Guide

It Girl Facebook Game Guide: cheats, hints, tips, tricks, strategiesIt Girl is a new Facebook game for girls that has become extremely popular in a short period of time, earning, up to this point, 3.3 million monthly active users on Facebook since its debut just around a month ago. In It Girl, you get to customize your girl’s look, shop at all sorts of stores for new clothes, earn money and spend money on the clothes and going to the salon in order to increase your “hotness”, and build your “clique”, as well as indulge your inner shopaholic and build up your “closet bonus” by increasing the size of your clothing collection the more you have, the more points you get for the “closet bonus”, no matter which clothing items you’re wearing or not wearing. All of this goes towards winning “showdowns” against other girls, which earns you money and experience points.Do you want to become the hottest, most jet setting, with it partying girl, winning every showdown you engage in? Then read the following tips to learn how.Facebook and Google+ game cheats, tips, tricks, hints and strategiesThe It Girl Cheats, Tips and Information BlogRight now, unfortunately, there isn’t very much available in this game in the way of cheats. Cheats wouldn’t help too much in this game anyways, because it’s really not a tough game to do well in, become a high level girl, or make a lot of money. However, these tips and tricks will make it easier to succeed in It Girl.First of all, you earn money in many ways you earn a lot of cheap jerseys bonuses in this game, and those can account for a good portion of the money. But the biggest money earner in this game, is simply waiting around. You earn an hourly salary simply for doing nothing in this game just log into the game, and there will be a stack of cash for every hour that you haven’t played the game. Each one is worth more depending on what level you’re at. Click the bonus cash stacks to earn your money.This applies to all of your bonus money, as well when you beat girls in showdowns, you will see cash and stars fall to the floor, cheap jerseys and you need to pick them up to add them to your stash of money and experience points.Money doesn’t matter very much in It Girl the most important aspects of the game are energy, confidence and experience points. However, money will buy you not only a new wardrobe, but confidence boosters (such as bronzer and makeup), and energy boosters (fancy coffee drinks and energy drinks). If you buy the confidence and energy boosters, you’ll add them to your purse, so rather than being used right away, you can use them whenever you want. When you level up, you regain all of your confidence and energy back, so don’t waste your energy boosters when you’re close to leveling it simply wait around cheap jerseys for a little bit and let your confidence and energy replenish naturally, then use your confidence and energy on shopping and winning showdowns to level up.The easiest way to win more showdowns is by building your “clique”. You do this by inviting your Facebook friends to play the game and join your clique, which can be accomplished not only by posting invite bulletins, but simply adding people on the game’s fan pages’ “add me” lists, or by adding people who are already on “add me” lists as friends. Build a massive clique this way.Build up your closet points by buying cheap items of clothing, no matter how low their hotless level is. Just load your closet up with items in general. Even if you never wear them, they still contribute to your “hotness”.When you’re dressing your character, layer as many different items of clothing as possible in order to maximize the hotness points. Even if your character’s style ends up looking flat out ridiculous and overlayered, your hotness will still increase, and the goal with dressing your character, is to have the most hotness points.If you need to build your character up and you want to win easy showdowns, you can attend events over and over again just attend the same events over and over if you know you can easily win showdowns and get the bonuses.The best way to build quick levels and earn experience, though, especially without spending money, is to go to new stores and “search” all of the shelves and racks. Searching costs nothing and earns you bonuses, but it does use up energy quickly.To maximize how much experience you earn for your energy and confidence, alternate back and forth between shopping and showdowns, so that you can not only deplete both of them equally, but earn them back equally.That’s it for now. Got any more tips? Post them in comments!It Girl for Facebook: How to get a carOne of the biggest new features that has been added to It Girl recently is the fact that you wholesale jerseys from china can now unlock and buy cars in It Girl. The cars have both a fuelIt Girl for Facebook: How to get a boyfriend and keep him happyIt Girl is one of the top girl games of all time on Facebook, with a lot of different modes of gameplay. One of the newer features of It Girl is that yourIt Girl Showdown Cheats: Win showdowns and get an epic win almost every timeIt Girl is the Paris Hilton Simulator of Facebook games, but if you’re reading this you already know what it is about. Its nearly 6.7 million monthly active users speak to its popularity. In this game, you are a girl who is trying to become the ‘it girl’ by.You can help the HubPages community highlight top quality content by ranking this article up or down.Useful {143} Funny {45} Awesome {56} Beautiful {66} Interesting {13}Sas 4 years agoThe first few levels keep doing the lowest party. It costs 1 dollar and you get a bonus of 5 reward points. All you need to do is one showdown. This is a very good start point.Articles Connexes:


    this is fantastic! it will help with my understanding of Native stereotypes for a school assignment 😀